콜리지의 이아고: “동기 없는 악,” 혹은 “지성 속의 모든 의지”
Coleridge's Iago: “Motiveless Malignancy,” or “All Will in Intellect”
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This essay looks at Iago's evil as described by Samuel Taylor Coleridge as "motiveless malignancy," or "all will in intellect" from the perspective of his concept of evil. According to Coleridge, evil is closely related to will. For him will is a spiritual faculty which renders a human being an individual being. Will is "our individuality" and "the ground of selfhood and freedom". But, will is also the origin of evil. Once our will accords to, and is in harmony with God's will, it is good. However, as soon as our will opposes or recoils from God's will, it becomes evil. Our will, for Coleridge, inevitably wills itself to be individual in order to be an individual being. In doing so will is not in harmony with God's will and thus fallen into Original Sin. He considers it the universal condition of human beings. Coleridge argues that man is in the middle state between the actual good and the potential evil. However, the more he wills himself to forsake "the Moral Law" the greater potential of evil in him is actualized. Iago, for Coleridge, is the embodiment of his concept of evil. He is a character trying to implement his will over others without any sense of morality. Being proud of his intellect, he despises others and intends to overpower them. Coleridge characterizes this aspect of Iago as "all will in intellect". Iago's ego wills himself to be a center of all. As a person having an egotistical will and a sense of intellectual superiority, he has the impulse of ruining others, especially his superiors. From this will, he tries to find motives justifying his evil behavior. Coleridge himself explains the difference between will and motive, arriving at a conclusion that what determines people's behavior is not motive but will. For Coleridge, Iago goes through with his evil actions not because he has found some motives for them, such as Cassio's unjustifiable promotion or Othello's or Cassio's suspectible love affair with his wife but because he is a person who has a will to dominate and control others. In this respect, what he calls Iago's "motiveless malignancy" does not literally mean malignancy without motives but malignancy originated from will.
Abstract
This essay looks at Iago's evil as described by Samuel Taylor Coleridge as "motiveless malignancy," or "all will in intellect" from the perspective of his concept of evil. According to Coleridge, evil is closely related to will. For him will is a spiritual faculty which renders a human being an individual being. Will is "our individuality" and "the ground of selfhood and freedom". But, will is also the origin of evil. Once our will accords to, and is in harmony with God's will, it is good. However, as soon as our will opposes or recoils from God's will, it becomes evil. Our will, for Coleridge, inevitably wills itself to be individual in order to be an individual being. In doing so will is not in harmony with God's will and thus fallen into Original Sin. He considers it the universal condition of human beings. Coleridge argues that man is in the middle state between the actual good and the potential evil. However, the more he wills himself to forsake "the Moral Law" the greater potential of evil in him is actualized. Iago, for Coleridge, is the embodiment of his concept of evil. He is a character trying to implement his will over others without any sense of morality. Being proud of his intellect, he despises others and intends to overpower them. Coleridge characterizes this aspect of Iago as "all will in intellect". Iago's ego wills himself to be a center of all. As a person having an egotistical will and a sense of intellectual superiority, he has the impulse of ruining others, especially his superiors. From this will, he tries to find motives justifying his evil behavior. Coleridge himself explains the difference between will and motive, arriving at a conclusion that what determines people's behavior is not motive but will. For Coleridge, Iago goes through with his evil actions not because he has found some motives for them, such as Cassio's unjustifiable promotion or Othello's or Cassio's suspectible love affair with his wife but because he is a person who has a will to dominate and control others. In this respect, what he calls Iago's "motiveless malignancy" does not literally mean malignancy without motives but malignancy originated from will.
참고문헌 (23)
- Adelman, Janet, "Iago's Alter Ego: Race as Projection in Othello", Shakespeare Quarterly, 48, pp.125~142 (1997)
- Barbeau. Jeffrey W., "Coleridge, The Bible, and Religion" (2008), Palgrave Macmillan
- Bodkin, Maud, "Archetypal Patterns in Poetry: Psychological Studies of Imagination" (1963), Oxford University Press
- Bradley, A. C., "Iago in: Shakespeare's Tragedies", pp.93~98 (1968), Penguin Books
- Coleridge, Samuel Taylor, "The Notebooks of Samuel Taylor Coleridge 8vols" (1957), Pantheon Books and Routledge & Kegan Paul
- Coleridge, Samuel Taylor, "Lectures 1808-1819: On Literature 2vols" (1984), Princeton University Press and Routledge
- Coleridge, Samuel Taylor, "Aids to Reflection" (1993), Princeton University Press
- Coleridge, Samuel Taylor, "Opus Maximum. Ed. Thomas McFarland" (2002), Princeton University Press
- Evans, Robert C., "Flattery in Shakespeare's Othello: The Relevance of Plutarch and Sir Thomas Elyot", Comparative Drama, 35, pp.1~41 (2001)
- Grady, Hugh, "Iago and the dialectic of enlightenment: reason, will and desire in Othello", Criticism: A Quarterly for Literature and the Arts, 37, pp.537~558 (1995)
- Hedley, Douglas, "oleridge, Philosophy and Religion: Aids to Reflection and the Mirror of the Spirit" (2000), Cambridge University Press
- Hornback, Robert, "Emblems of Folly in the First Othello: Renaissance Blackface, Moor's Coat, and "Muckender", Comparative Drama, 35, pp.69~99 (2001)
- Jasper, David, "Coleridge as Poet and Religious Thinker" (1985), Pickwick Publications
- Lockridge, Laurence. S., "Coleridge the Moralist" (1977), Cornell University Press
- Macaulay, Marcia, "When Chaos Is Come Again: Narrative and Narrative Analysis in Othello", Style, 39, pp.259~276 (2005)
- Reardon, Bernard M.G., "From Coleridge to Gore" (1971), Longman
- Sapiro, Barbara A., "Psychoanalysis and the Problem of Evil: Debating Othello in the Classroom", American Imago, 60, pp.481~499 (2003)
- Saunders, Ben, "Iago's Clyster: Purgation, Anality, and the Civilizing Process", Shakespeare Quarterly, 55, pp.148~176 (2004)
- Shakespeare, William, "The Tragedy of Othello" (1960), Penguin Books
- Shakespeare, William, "Macbeth" (1997), Thomas Nelson & Sons Ltd.
- Smith, Shawn, "Love, Pity, and Deception in Othello", Papers on Language and Literature, 44, pp.3~51 (2008)
- Spivak, Bernard, "Shakespeare and the Allegory of Evil: The History of a Metaphor in Relation to His Major Villans" (1958), Columbia University Press
- Weidhorn, Manfred, "Motive Hunting", The Midwest Quarterly, 40, pp.260~273 (1999)