Can You Violate the Conjunction Condition in Korean? Tight vs. Loose Coordination
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Zhang (2010) argues that the Coordinate Structure Constraint (CSC) can be violated as in extraction of collective-reading conjuncts in Chinese he/gen coordinate construction. Likewise, Bošković (2013, 2017 a,b, 2018), Stjepanović (2014) and Oda (2016) argue that movement of the head of an island voids islandhood and thus CSC can be violated in some cases. Specifically, Oda (2016) claims that Japanese allows extraction of conjuncts in violation of CSC. This paper argues that the conjunctive -wa in Korean does not allow violation of the conjunct condition of CSC, even when it has collective interpretation, based on the data related to plural agreement marker –tul, reciprocal pronoun selo(each other), and intentional/optative verbs. This paper concludes by suggesting that, cross-linguistically, extractable conjunct is in ‘loose’-coordination relation with the other conjunct in that it is base-generated at the edge of coordinate structure, while non-extractable one, as a ‘tightly’ coordinated conjunct, is within coordinate structure.
Abstract
Zhang (2010) argues that the Coordinate Structure Constraint (CSC) can be violated as in extraction of collective-reading conjuncts in Chinese he/gen coordinate construction. Likewise, Bošković (2013, 2017 a,b, 2018), Stjepanović (2014) and Oda (2016) argue that movement of the head of an island voids islandhood and thus CSC can be violated in some cases. Specifically, Oda (2016) claims that Japanese allows extraction of conjuncts in violation of CSC. This paper argues that the conjunctive -wa in Korean does not allow violation of the conjunct condition of CSC, even when it has collective interpretation, based on the data related to plural agreement marker –tul, reciprocal pronoun selo(each other), and intentional/optative verbs. This paper concludes by suggesting that, cross-linguistically, extractable conjunct is in ‘loose’-coordination relation with the other conjunct in that it is base-generated at the edge of coordinate structure, while non-extractable one, as a ‘tightly’ coordinated conjunct, is within coordinate structure.
참고문헌 (35)
- 안덕호, "NP-Juxtaposition and Co-Involvement: A Uniform Analysis of Conjunctives, Comitatives, and Comparatives", 생성문법연구, 28(1), pp.187~211 (2018), 한국생성문법학회[DOI]
- Bošković, Željko, "Rescue by PF deletion, traces as (non)interveners, and the that-trace effect", Linguistic Inquiry, 42, pp.1~44 (2011)
- Bošković, Željko., "Deep insights, broad perspectives: Essays in honor of Mamoru Saito", pp.56~93 (2013), Kaitakusha
- Bošković, Željko, "On the Coordinate Structure Constraint, Islandhood, Phases, and Rescue by PF-deletion", ms, pp.2017
- Bošković, Željko, "On the Coordinate Structure Constraint and the Adjunct Condition", ms, pp.2017
- Bošković, Željko, "On The Coordinate Structure Constraint, Across-the-Board-Movement, Phases, and Labeling", Linguistic Inquiry (2018)
- Choe, Hyon Sook, "Restructuring Parameters and Complex Predicates: Transformational Approach", Doctoral, pp.1988
- 정대호, "Dummy Plural Marker -Tul in Korean: Agree and Spread", 현대문법연구, (72), pp.67~84 (2013), 현대문법학회
- Haspelmath, Martin, "Coordinating constructions", pp.3~39 (2004), Benjamins
- Jespersen, Otto, "Philosophy of Grammar" (1924), Norton
- 전영철, "한국어의 복수성과 총칭성", 한정성, 2004, pp.8(2), 27~46[DOI]
- Kang, Arum, "On pluralizing event: plural marking event pluralizer tul in Korean", Journee Semantique et Modelisation (2009), Universite Paris dederot – Paris 7
- Kim, C.-H., "The Korean Plural Marker Tul and Its Implications", Doctoral, pp.2005
- Kim, Young-Hee, "Aspects of the conjunction marker ‘wa’", The Korean Language and Literature, 65∙66, pp.53~81 (1974)
- Kim, Young-Hee, "Taychingkwankyeywa cepsok cosa ‘wa’(Symmetric Relations and Conjunctive Marker –wa)", Han-Geul, 154, pp.41~63 (1974)
- Kim, Young-Hee, "Particle wa in the comitative constructions", Journal of Korean Linguistics, 38, pp.155~180 (2001)
- Lee, Hangyu, "Harvard Studies in Korean Linguistics III", pp.513~528 (1991)
- Lee, Ki-Mwun, "Kukesa Kayseol (On the History of Korean)" (1976), Top Press
- Lefebvre, Claire, "Coordinating constructions" (2004), Benjamins
- Lord, Carol, "Serial verbs in transition", Studies in African Linguistics, 4(3), pp.269~295 (1973)
- McNally, Louise, "Comitative coordination : A case study in group formation", Natural Language and Linguistic Theory, 11, pp.347~379 (1993)
- Mithun, Marianne, "Clause Combining in Grammar and Discourse", pp.331~359 (1988), John Benjamins
- Moon, Seung-Chul, "Harvard Studies in Korean Linguistics VI", pp.355~369 (1995)
- No, Hwang-Jin, "A Study on -Wa in Korean", Dong-Ak Language and Literature Studies, 25 (1990), Dong-Ak Society of Language and Literature
- Nam, Ki-Sim, "Thossi ‘wa", kwa’uy ssuimey tayhaye (On the Use of ‘wa, Tongpanghakci, pp.1990, 66[DOI]
- Oda, Hiromune, "Two types of the Coordinate Structure Constraint and rescue by PF deletion", Presented at the North East Linguistics Society (2016)
- Park, Myung-Kwan, "A Minimalist Approach to Plural Marker Licensing in Korean", MIT Working Papers in Linguistics, pp.193~207 (1993)
- Park, So-Young, "Harvard Studies in Korean Linguistics XI", pp.697~710 (2006)
- Ross, John Robert, "Constraints on Variables in Syntax", Doctoral, pp.1967
- Stassen, Leon, "AND-languages and WITH-languages", Linguistic Typology, 4(1), pp.1~55 (2000)
- Stjepanović, Sandra, "Left branch extraction and the Coordinate Structure Constraint", Proceedings of the North East Linguistic Society, 44, pp.157~170 (2014), GLSA
- Watanabe, Akira, "Subjacency and S-Structure Movement of WH-IN-SITU", Journal of East Asian Linguistics, 1, pp.255~291 (1992)
- Yim, Changguk, "The Semantics of Non-nominal ‘Tul’ in Korean", Journal of the International Circle of Korean Linguistics, 11, pp.183~202 (2002)
- Yoon, James Hey Suk, "Conjunction reduction and its consequences for noun phrase morphosyntax in Korean", Proceedings of the West Coast Conference on Formal Linguistics, 24, pp.379~387 (2005), Cascadilla Proceedings Project
- Zhang, Niina Ning, "Coordination in syntax" (2010), Cambridge University Press