AHP를 이용한 해군 호위함 전투효과 측정에 관한 연구
A Study on the Measuring of Combat Effectiveness for Naval Frigates Using Analytic Hierarchy Process
2
조회
0
다운로드
5
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Modern combat has been extended to the concept of real-time response to a variety of threats simultaneously occurring in vast areas. In order to quick command determination and accurate engagement in these threats, the combat system has emerged in frigate. Frigates conduct anti-surface, anti-submarine, and anti-aircraft as the core forces of the fleet. In this study, the combat effectiveness measures naval frigates using AHP (analytic hierarchy process) method. A hierarchical structure for measuring the combat effectiveness was developed, and weights of criteria were calculated by expert surveys and pair-wise comparisons. In addition, the combat effectiveness of frigates was synthesized and compared. The weights for each attribute were calculated, and the weights for the three main attributes were in the order of act (0.594), evaluate (0.277), and see (0.129). As a result of calculating the weight, anti surface warfare (0.203) was the highest. The combat effectiveness of FFG Batch-III, which has advanced hardware and software and improved combat system capabilities, see (1.73 to 2.56 times), evaluate (1.68 to 2.08 times), and act (1.31 to 3.80 times) better than the comparative frigate. In summarizing the combat effects of the frigate, FFG Batch-III was 1.41~2.95 times superior to the comparative frigate. In particular, a group of experts evaluated the act importantly, resulting in better combat effectiveness.
Abstract
Modern combat has been extended to the concept of real-time response to a variety of threats simultaneously occurring in vast areas. In order to quick command determination and accurate engagement in these threats, the combat system has emerged in frigate. Frigates conduct anti-surface, anti-submarine, and anti-aircraft as the core forces of the fleet. In this study, the combat effectiveness measures naval frigates using AHP (analytic hierarchy process) method. A hierarchical structure for measuring the combat effectiveness was developed, and weights of criteria were calculated by expert surveys and pair-wise comparisons. In addition, the combat effectiveness of frigates was synthesized and compared. The weights for each attribute were calculated, and the weights for the three main attributes were in the order of act (0.594), evaluate (0.277), and see (0.129). As a result of calculating the weight, anti surface warfare (0.203) was the highest. The combat effectiveness of FFG Batch-III, which has advanced hardware and software and improved combat system capabilities, see (1.73 to 2.56 times), evaluate (1.68 to 2.08 times), and act (1.31 to 3.80 times) better than the comparative frigate. In summarizing the combat effects of the frigate, FFG Batch-III was 1.41~2.95 times superior to the comparative frigate. In particular, a group of experts evaluated the act importantly, resulting in better combat effectiveness.
참고문헌 (20)
- 조기홍, "AHP & 모수추정법을 이용한 차기 다련장로켓의 비용대 효과분석", 한국군사과학기술학회지, 13(1), pp.84~90 (2010), 한국군사과학기술학회
- Chung, S. M., "A Study on the Operation Tactics for the Ulsan Class Batch-3 Com- bat System" (2019), Naval Academy
- Jolene, M., "An Analysis of the Open Architecture Warfare System Do- main Model for Surface Time Critical Targets", Master, pp.2007
- 정환식, "네트워크 효과를 고려한 C4I 체계 전투력 상승효과 평가", 한국산업경영시스템학회지, 33(2), pp.23~32 (2010), 한국산업경영시스템학회
- Kang, S.C., "A Study on the Analysis of Combat Effectiveness of the Ground Tactical C4I Systems using AHP", Master, pp.2001
- 김지훈, "전투함의 구조적 효율성 분석을 위한 AHP", DEA-AR 모형 설계, 2019, pp.45(1), 59~72[DOI]
- Kim, J. W., "Prin- ciples and Understanding of Combat System, Chang- won" (2016), Naval Education & Training Command
- Kim, K.T., "Efficiency Evaluation for Battleships by using AHP & DEA Model", Journal of Military Science and Technology Studies, 1(2), pp.68~91 (2007)
- Lee, I. H., "5-year plan for shipping reconstruction and Established Ocean Promotion Corporation", Maritime Korea, 543, pp.20~21 (2018)
- 이재문, "시뮬레이션 및 AHP기법을 이용한 공격헬기 전투효과 분석", 한국시뮬레이션학회 논문지, 19(3), pp.63~70 (2010), 한국시뮬레이션학회
- Lee, M.H, "Development of Defense Simulation Model for Ground Weapon System Effectiveness Analysis", Proceedings of the Korea Society for Simulation, pp.131~136 (2002)
- Lee, S. E., "Development Status and Future Directions of Naval Combat System", Journal of Maritime Strategy, 150, pp.1~24 (2011)
- Lee, S.Y., "A Study on the Assessment of Force Improvement Effectiveness of KNTDS", Jour- nal of the Military Operations Research Society of Korea, 27(2), pp.56~75 (2001)
- Ministry of Government Legislation, "Act on Organization of National Armed Forces, Ver. 10821(3)", ~ (2011)
- 5-year plan for ship- ping reconstruction, "Ministry of Oceans and Fisheries", ~ (2018)
- 박송기, "지상전술 C4I 체계의 통합화력 운영간 전투력 상승효과 평가에 관한 연구", 한국국방경영분석학회지, 29(1), pp.8~27 (2003), 한국국방경영분석학회
- "ROK Navy Headquarters, Naval doctrine", ~ (2017)
- "ROK Navy Homepage" (2020)[URL]
- Saaty, T. L., "Decision Making for Leaders; The Analytic Hierarchy Process Decisions in an Complex World" (1982), RWS Publications
- Song, Y.I., "A Study on the Improvement Effectiveness of Ship Combat System by using the Si- mulation Model", Journal of Military Science and Tech- nology Studies, 3(1), pp.74~93 (2009)