DSM-IV 단기정신병적장애와 ICD-10 급성일과성정신병적장애의 임상적 유사점과 차이점
Similarities and Differences between DSM-IV Brief Psychotic Disorder and ICD-10 Acute and Transient Psychotic Disorder
2
조회
0
다운로드
1
인용
0
참고문헌
초록
Time is the most important factor in defining the diagnostic concepts of DSM-IV brief psychotic disorder (BPD) and ICD-10 acute and transient psychotic disorder (ATPD). Time factor is more complicated in ICD-10 ATPD than in DSM-IV BPD because he first time factor in ICD-10 ATPD concerns the development of symptoms (acute onset within 2 weeks), and the second factor,the duration of an episode, depends on the subtypes of ICD-10 ATPD. For instance, the duration of an episode in acute polymorphic psychotic disorder (APPD) with symptoms of schizophrenia must not exceed I month, while APPD without symptoms of schizophrenia may occur forup to three months. Despite the differences with respect to time factor in DSM-IV BPD and ICD-10ATPD, it is not necessary to consider them as separate diagnostic entitie because they are identical in almost all of the essential clinical parameters. The strict criterion of episode duration in DSM-IV BPD should therefore be reconsidered. The APPD within ICD-10 ATPD subtypes, which is very similar to both cycloid psychosis and bouff´ee d´elirante, has a significant diagnostic concordance with DSM-IV BPD, and can be distinguished more clearly from schizophrenia and bipolar schizoaffective disorder. In contrast, ASPD not only has similarities to schizophrenia but also to bipolar schizoaffective disorder. This means that ASPD could function as a bridge between one end of the psychotic continuum occupied by schizophrenia and the opposite end occupied by major affective disorder. Taking this into consideration, ICD-10 ATPD could be much more homogeneous if APPD was not combined with ASPD. On the other hand, the symptomatologic polymorphism carries the most relevant distinguishing power in differentiating the subtypes of ICD-10 ATPD, so the distinction of APPD with and without symptoms of schizophrenia is not needed.
Abstract
Time is the most important factor in defining the diagnostic concepts of DSM-IV brief psychotic disorder (BPD) and ICD-10 acute and transient psychotic disorder (ATPD). Time factor is more complicated in ICD-10 ATPD than in DSM-IV BPD because he first time factor in ICD-10 ATPD concerns the development of symptoms (acute onset within 2 weeks), and the second factor,the duration of an episode, depends on the subtypes of ICD-10 ATPD. For instance, the duration of an episode in acute polymorphic psychotic disorder (APPD) with symptoms of schizophrenia must not exceed I month, while APPD without symptoms of schizophrenia may occur forup to three months. Despite the differences with respect to time factor in DSM-IV BPD and ICD-10ATPD, it is not necessary to consider them as separate diagnostic entitie because they are identical in almost all of the essential clinical parameters. The strict criterion of episode duration in DSM-IV BPD should therefore be reconsidered. The APPD within ICD-10 ATPD subtypes, which is very similar to both cycloid psychosis and bouff´ee d´elirante, has a significant diagnostic concordance with DSM-IV BPD, and can be distinguished more clearly from schizophrenia and bipolar schizoaffective disorder. In contrast, ASPD not only has similarities to schizophrenia but also to bipolar schizoaffective disorder. This means that ASPD could function as a bridge between one end of the psychotic continuum occupied by schizophrenia and the opposite end occupied by major affective disorder. Taking this into consideration, ICD-10 ATPD could be much more homogeneous if APPD was not combined with ASPD. On the other hand, the symptomatologic polymorphism carries the most relevant distinguishing power in differentiating the subtypes of ICD-10 ATPD, so the distinction of APPD with and without symptoms of schizophrenia is not needed.
참고문헌 (39)
- Leonhard K, "Cycloid psychoses--endogenous psychoses which are neither schizophrenic nor manic-depressive", J Ment Sci, 107, pp.633~648 (1961)
- Perris C, "A study of cycloid psychosis", Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, (Suppl 253), pp.1~77 (1974)
- Pichot P, "The concept of ‘bouffee delirante’ with special reference to the Scandinavian concept of reactive psychosis", Psychopathology, 19, pp.35~43 (1986)
- Maj M, "The evolution of some European diagnostic concepts relevant to the category of schizoaffective psychoses", Psychopathology, 17, pp.158~167 (1984)
- McQueen J, "Psychiatry: A Textbook for Students and Physicians (Translation of the 6th edition of: Psychiatrie. Ein Lehrbuch fur Studirende und Arzte.) Canton" (1990), Science History Publications
- Kraepelin E, "Die Erscheinungsformen des Irreseins. Zeitschrift fur die gesamte", Neurologie und Psychiatrie, 62, pp.1~29 (1920)
- Pillmann F, "An analysis of Wernicke’s original case records: his contribution to the concept of cycloid psychoses", Hist Psychiatry, 11, pp.355~369 (2000)
- Perris C, "The case for the independence of cycloid psychotic disorder from the schizoaffective disorders in Schizoaffective psychoses", pp.272~308 (1986), Springer
- Sigmund D, "The cycloid type and its differentiation from core schizophrenia: a phenomenological approach", Compr Psychiatry, 40, pp.4~18 (1999)
- Zarate CA, "Bipolar disorders: 100 years after manic-depressive insanity" (2000), Kluwer Academic Publishers
- Beckmann H, "Cycloid psychoses and their differentiation from affective and schizophrenic psychoses in Contemporary Psychiatry", pp.387~398 (2001), Springer
- Leonhard K, "Classification of endogenous psychoses and their differential etiology" (1999), Springer
- Perris C, "Cycloid psychoses and their relation to the major psychoses in Biological psychiatry", pp.447~450 (1981), Elsevier
- Pichot P, "A comparison of different national concepts of schizoaffective psychosis in Schizoaffective Psychoses", pp.8~17 (1986), Springer
- Pull CB, "Nosological position of schizoaffective psychoses in France", Psychiatrica Clinica, 16, pp.141~148 (1983)
- Pichot P, "The diagnosis and classification of mental disorders in French-speaking countries: background, current views and comparison with other nomenclatures", Psychol Med, 12, pp.475~492 (1982)
- Ferrey G, "Evolution et pronostic des troubles psychotiques aigus (bouffee delirante polymorphe)", Encephale, 25, pp.26~32 (1999)
- Singer L, "Bouffees delirantes et schizophrenie: etude catamnestique comparative de deux groupes de patients", Ann Med Psychol, 144, pp.1029~1044 (1986)
- Lazaratou H, "Bouffee delirante et evolution schizophrenique: role pronostique de la classification DSM-III", Psychiatry and Psychobiologie, 3, pp.297~304 (1989)
- Lanczik M, "Puerperal and cycloid psychoses. Results of a retrospective study", Psychopathology, 23, pp.220~227 (1990)
- Rohde A, "Schizoaffective disorders with and without onset in the puerperium", Eur Arch Psychiatry Clin Neurosci, 242, pp.27~33 (1992)
- Schopf J, "Follow-up and family study of postpartum psychoses. Part I: Overview", Eur Arch Psychiatry Clin Neurosci, 244, pp.101~111 (1994)
- Schopf J, "Follow-up and family study of postpartum psychoses. Part IV: Schizophreniform psychoses and brief reactive psychoses: lack of nosololgical relation to schizophrenia", Eur Arch Psychiatry Clin Neurosci, 244, pp.141~144 (1994)
- Pillmann F, "The concordance of ICD-10 acute and transient psychosis and DSM-IV brief psychotic disorder", Psychol Med, 32, pp.525~533 (2002)
- Dahl AA, "Convergence of American and Scandinavican diagnoses of functional psychoses", Compr Psychiatry, 33, pp.13~16 (1992)
- Okasha A, "Presentation of acute psychosis in an Egyptian sample: a transcultural comparison", Compr Psychiatry, 34, pp.4~9 (1993)
- Ungvari GS, "Reactive psychoses revisited", Aust N Z J Psychiatry, 34, pp.458~467 (2000)
- Susser E, "Delineation of acute and transient psychotic disorders in a developing country setting", Br J Psychiatry, 167, pp.216~219 (1995)
- Mojtabai R, "Duration of remitting psychoses with acute onset. Implications for ICD-10", Br J Psychiatry, 176, pp.576~580 (2000)
- Marneros A, "Acute and Transient Psychoses. Cambridge", pp.173~196 (2004), Cambridge University Press
- Koehler K, "Prognostic prediction in RDC schizo-affective disorder on the basis of first-rank symptoms weighted in terms of outcome", Psychiatr Clin, 16, pp.186~197 (1983)
- Marneros A, "Frequency of occurrence of Schneider’s first rank symptoms in Schizophrenia", Eur Arch Psychiatry Neurol Sci, 234, pp.78~82 (1984)
- Marneros A, "Schizophrenic first-rank symptoms in organic mental disorders", Br J Psychiatry, 152, pp.625~628 (1988)
- Mellor CS, "Change of diagnosis in schizophrenia and first-rank symptoms: an eight-year follow-up", Compr Psychiatry, 22, pp.184~188 (1981)
- Jorgensen P, "Acute and transient psychotic disorder: comorbidity with personality disorder", Acta Psychiatr Scand, 94, pp.460~464 (1996)
- Jorgensen P, "Acute and transient psychotic disorder: a 1-year follow-up study", Acta Psychiatr Scand, 96, pp.150~154 (1997)
- Mattsson B, "Cycloid psychoses: aspects of therapy and possible prevention of relapses", Nordisk Psykiatrisk Tidsskrift, 27, pp.386~391 (1973)
- Neumann J, "Psychopharmakologische Erfahrungen mit Methophenazin unter besonderer Berucksichtigung der Aufteilung der endogenen Psychosen nach Leonhard", Psychiatrie, Neurologie und Medizinische Psychologie, 1, pp.11~17 (1966)
- Marneros A, "Acute and Transient Psychoses", pp.120~124 (2004), Cambridge University Press