조선시대 남성복식에 발현된 성리학적 몸 인식
Perception of the Neo-Confucian body in men’s dress during the Joseon Dynasty
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Comprehending the prevailing ideals of the body within a specific era requires grasping the intricate interplay between social phenomena and the evolution of clothing. Accordingly, this study investigates the distinctive facets of the perception of the Neo-Confucian body as reflected in men’s dress during the Joseon Dynasty. We examine a comprehensive body of scholarship, literature, and historical records concerning the body and dress. Additionally, we also employ a framework developed by M. Y. Kim, which categorizes the Neo-Confucian body in three ways: as the natural body, the cultural body, and the body as a fully-realized moral subject. Our findings unveil three crucial insights: firstly, guided by Neo-Confucian discourse positing appearance as a manifestation of innate energy (氣), men’s dress was deliberately designed to demarcate stylistic distinctions in women’s dress; secondly, the Chinese gwan (冠) was employed as a tool of self-cultivation (修身) to symbolize the legitimacy of Joseon’s Neo-Confucian governance; and thirdly, sim-ui (深衣), a philosophical emblem of Confucianism extensively represented across through an intensified exploration of historical sources, served as a means to consolidate the political standing of the Neo-Confucian faction. As a consequence of these factors, the attire of noble men conferred upon them both sexual and moral ascendancy as political entities; men’s dress became a visual manifestation of the legitimacy of their power, thus embodying Neo-Confucian ideals. This study carries significance by applying a discourse analysis approach to Korean dress research and elucidating the factors underlying the development of men’s dress during the Joseon Dynasty.
Abstract
Comprehending the prevailing ideals of the body within a specific era requires grasping the intricate interplay between social phenomena and the evolution of clothing. Accordingly, this study investigates the distinctive facets of the perception of the Neo-Confucian body as reflected in men’s dress during the Joseon Dynasty. We examine a comprehensive body of scholarship, literature, and historical records concerning the body and dress. Additionally, we also employ a framework developed by M. Y. Kim, which categorizes the Neo-Confucian body in three ways: as the natural body, the cultural body, and the body as a fully-realized moral subject. Our findings unveil three crucial insights: firstly, guided by Neo-Confucian discourse positing appearance as a manifestation of innate energy (氣), men’s dress was deliberately designed to demarcate stylistic distinctions in women’s dress; secondly, the Chinese gwan (冠) was employed as a tool of self-cultivation (修身) to symbolize the legitimacy of Joseon’s Neo-Confucian governance; and thirdly, sim-ui (深衣), a philosophical emblem of Confucianism extensively represented across through an intensified exploration of historical sources, served as a means to consolidate the political standing of the Neo-Confucian faction. As a consequence of these factors, the attire of noble men conferred upon them both sexual and moral ascendancy as political entities; men’s dress became a visual manifestation of the legitimacy of their power, thus embodying Neo-Confucian ideals. This study carries significance by applying a discourse analysis approach to Korean dress research and elucidating the factors underlying the development of men’s dress during the Joseon Dynasty.
참고문헌 (58)
- Cheon, H., "A study on Chutzu’s theory of human mind and moral mind", doc-tor, pp.2009
- Chungbuk National University Museum., "조선시대 여인의 옷", ~ (2006)
- Connell, R. W., "Gender and power: Society, the person, and sexual politics" (1987), Stanford University Press
- Connell, R. W., "Masculinities" (2013), Imagine
- Deuchler, M., "The Confucian transformation of Korea : A study of society and ideology" (1992), Harvard University Press
- Douglas, M., "Natural symbols" (2014), Ehaksa
- Entwistle, J., "The fashioned body" (2013), Hansung University Press
- Foucault, M., "감시와 처벌: 감옥의 탄생" (2020), Nanam Publishing House
- Goffman, E., "Behavior in public places: Notes on the social organization of gatherings" (1963), Free Press
- Grosz, E. A., "Crossing boundaries: Feminisms and the critique of knowledges", pp.5~27 (1988), Allen & Unwin
- "능창대군 망건"[URL]
- Gyeonggi Provincial Museum., "진주류씨 합장묘 출토복식: 안성 대덕면 무능리", ~ (2006)
- Gyeonggi Provincial Museum., "의(衣)문(紋)의 조선: 옷" (2016), Minsokwon
- 하여주, "조선시대 의학서로 본 여성 몸 담론-『東醫寶鑑』과 『歷試漫筆』을 중심으로", 역사와경계, (109), pp.1~40 (2018), 부산경남사학회
- Hollander, A., "Seeing through clothes" (1993), University of California Press
- Hong, D. S., "몸과 문화: 인간의몸을 해석하는 다양한 문화담론들" (2009), Sungkyunkwan University Press
- Hong, N. Y., "동아시아 복식의 역사" (2012), Kyomunsa
- "退溪集"[URL]
- "芝峯類說"[URL]
- "星湖僿說"[URL]
- "磻溪隨錄"[URL]
- [URL]
- 정복철, "‘몸의 정치학’ 패러다임의 탐색 : 유의(儒醫) 전통에 있어서 ‘몸-정치’ 담론의 위상", Oughtopia (오토피아), 23(2), pp.177~216 (2008), 인류사회재건연구원
- Jeong, H. K., "심의" (1998), Kyungnam University Press
- 정예희, "조선시대 복식 풍속과 ‘복요(服妖)’ 논란", 역사와 담론, (62), pp.235~286 (2012), 호서사학회[DOI]
- 지신호, "조선 중기 한시에 나타나는 몸의 두 가지 양상 ―남명의 작품을 중심으로―", 한국문학이론과 비평, 14(3), pp.307~328 (2010), 한국문학이론과비평학회
- "박세당 초상"[URL]
- Kang, S. I., "몸의 역사, 몸의 문화" (2007), Humanist
- Kim, D. E., "A study on changing trends in the types of sim-ui and its factors in Joseon period", mater’s, pp.2019
- Kim, H., "조선시대 ‘남성’의 몸", 인문학 연구, 9, pp.15~39 (2002)
- Kim, M., "복식미학: 패션을 보는 시각과 패션에 대한 생각" (2013), Kyomunsa
- 김미영, "‘人心道心說’을 통해 본 성리학의 몸담론: 주희와 이율곡의 논의를 중심으로", 철학, 73, pp.5~26 (2002), 한국철학회
- Kim, S. Y., "Fashion and the body" (2007), Korea Studies Information
- Lee, I. J., "A study on the costume view found in Silhak in late years of Chosŏn Dynasty", doctoral, pp.2000
- Lee, I. J., "실학사상과 조선후기 服飾觀" (2009), Korea Studies Information
- 이경미, "남녀유별 禮의식(內外法)이 복식생활에 미친 영향에 관한 연구-조선후기 남녀 복식생활을 중심으로-", 복식, 57(1) (2007), 한국복식학회
- 이경미, "조선후기 類書類에 나타난 服飾觀 －『芝峯類說』『星湖僿說』『松南雜識』를 중심으로－", 역사민속학, (33), pp.73~114 (2010), 한국역사민속학회
- 이민선, "복식에 나타난 푸코와 메를로-퐁티의 몸 개념", 한국디자인포럼, (37), pp.97~108 (2012), 한국디자인트렌드학회[DOI]
- 이민선, "권력과 남성 패션에 표현된 미적 이미지", 복식문화연구, 11(2), pp.177~192 (2003), 복식문화학회
- 이민선, "권력 구조가 복식의 성적 표현에 미치는 영향", 복식, 56(5), pp.89~104 (2006), 한국복식학회
- "世祖實錄 卷3, 世祖 2年 3月 28日 丁酉 3번째 기사" (1863)[URL]
- "成宗實錄 卷13, 成宗 2年 12月 25日 壬辰 8번째 기사" (1863)[URL]
- "燕山君日記 卷58, 燕山 11年 6月 13日 丙寅 3번째 기사" (1863)[URL]
- "심득경초상"[URL]
- "신임 초상"[URL]
- "송시열초상"[URL]
- Park, K. S., "居家雜服攷" (2000), Seoksil
- Park, N. J., "씩씩한 남자 만들기: 한국의 이상적 남성성의 역사를 파헤치다" (2009), Purunyoksa
- Seoul Museum of History, "환생: 석주선박사 10주기 추모 출토복식 특별전", ~ (2006)
- Shilling, C., "The body and social theory" (1999), Nanam Publishing House
- 신동은, "성리학의 몸공부 이해", 교육철학연구, (32), pp.123~144 (2004), 한국교육철학학회
- Tayloy, L., "The study of dress history" (2002), Manchester University Press
- Wiesner-Hanks, M., "젠더의 역사" (2006), Yuksabipyoungsa
- 연희원, "복식(服飾, 패션)의 인식론적 기초 연구 -메를로-퐁티의 시각적", 촉각적 몸을 기반으로 -, 2011, pp.16, 177~208[DOI]
- Yim, E. H., "Representation and non-representation of the body in fashion", doctoral, pp.2006
- 임은혁, "한국복식과 서구복식에 나타난 몸과 복식에 관한 전통적인 시각 비교", 복식문화연구, 19(3), pp.501~517 (2011), 복식문화학회[DOI]
- Zhu, X., "(국역) 주자가례 全" (2005), Sungkyunkwan
- Zhu, X., "小學" (2013), Hongik Publishing