Russian-South Korean Security Relations Reconsidered: The Lost Two Decades of Promise and Perils
1
조회
0
다운로드
2
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
This article analyses the problems of comprehensive bilateral security relations between Russia and South Korea. The paper examines how the focus of the regional security cooperation building process between Russia and South Korea has evolved since the establishment of diplomatic relations. This paper contends that the two countries have put equal emphasis on both traditional and non-traditional security cooperation. However, the focus has gradually changed from the traditional to a non-traditional dimension. This study also maintains that in order to establish a favourable regional security environment, bilateral and multilateral cooperation among nation states is essential because regional economic security cooperation provides an opportunity to generate trust and confidence between nation states. Nonetheless, bilateral relations between Moscow and Seoul have developed quite slowly because both have underestimated the importance of regional economic security. As a result, the two countries have failed to cultivate full trust in each other. And neither side has had the motivation to deal with existing domestic obstacles such as the inherent economic difficulties of the Russian Far East, and the reluctance of the South Korean government and private sector to invest in the long term. Furthermore, bilateral security cooperation between the two countries has been hampered by external factors such as the North Korean nuclear issue and the dominating role the US or China has been playing in the Northeast Asian region.
Abstract
This article analyses the problems of comprehensive bilateral security relations between Russia and South Korea. The paper examines how the focus of the regional security cooperation building process between Russia and South Korea has evolved since the establishment of diplomatic relations. This paper contends that the two countries have put equal emphasis on both traditional and non-traditional security cooperation. However, the focus has gradually changed from the traditional to a non-traditional dimension. This study also maintains that in order to establish a favourable regional security environment, bilateral and multilateral cooperation among nation states is essential because regional economic security cooperation provides an opportunity to generate trust and confidence between nation states. Nonetheless, bilateral relations between Moscow and Seoul have developed quite slowly because both have underestimated the importance of regional economic security. As a result, the two countries have failed to cultivate full trust in each other. And neither side has had the motivation to deal with existing domestic obstacles such as the inherent economic difficulties of the Russian Far East, and the reluctance of the South Korean government and private sector to invest in the long term. Furthermore, bilateral security cooperation between the two countries has been hampered by external factors such as the North Korean nuclear issue and the dominating role the US or China has been playing in the Northeast Asian region.
참고문헌 (51)
- "Agence France Presse, August 19", ~ (2004)
- Ahn, Se Hyun., "Energy Alliance among South Korea, Russia and China : Potentials and Problems", The Journal of International Studies, 15(1), pp.105~135 (2010)
- Ahn, Se Hyun., "Framing Energy Security between Russia and South Korea? : Progress, Problems, and Prospects", Asian Survey, 50(3), pp.591~614 (2010)
- Ahn, Se Hyun., "Understanding Russia-South Korea Arms Trade : A Non-Traditional Security Approach", Armed Forces and Society, 35(3), pp.421~435 (2009)
- Ahn, Se Hyun., "Russian Policy Toward North Korea’s Nuclear Proliferation", IIRI(Ilmin International Relations Institute)Review, 12(1), pp.147~171 (2007)
- Ahn, Se Hyun., "Energy Security in Northeast Asia: Putin, Progress, and Problems", LSE Asia Research Centre (ARC), 20(20), pp.1~24 (2007)
- Se Hyun Ahn, "운송네트워크 협력 및 지역경제안보의 시사점 : 시베리아와 한반도 철도의 연결 사업을 중심으로", The Korean Journal of Policy Studies, 21(1), pp.1~30 (2006), 서울대학교행정대학원
- 안세현, "나호트카 지유무역지대의 정치경제학", 슬라브硏究, 22(2), pp.49~78 (2006), 러시아연구소
- 안세현, "자연자원관리보호 : 러시아와 남한간 어업협정", The Korean Journal of Policy Studies, 20(1), pp.1~33 (2005), 서울대학교행정대학원
- Ahn, Se Hyun, "Presentation Paper, Robert Scalapino Symposium of the National Asia Research Program, National Asia Research Program West Coast Symposium, Se Hyun Ahn, “Ensuring Energy Security in Northeast Asia?: Pipelines, Progress, Problems and Prospects,”", organized by National Bureau of Asian Research, 10 (2010), National Bureau of Asian Research
- Ahn, Se Hyun, "Presentation Paper, The Six Party Talks and Korea’s Energy Security, Se Hyun Ahn, “Russia’s Energy Gambit in Northeast Asia Focusing on the Korean Peninsula”", The Sam Nunn School of International Affairs, Center for International Strategy (2009), The Sam Nunn School of International Affairs
- Ahn, Se Hyun, "Northeast Asia’s Kovykta Conundrum: A Decade of Promise and Peril", Asia Policy (The National Bureau of Asian Research, NBR), 5, pp.105~140 (2008)
- Bazhanov, Evgeniy, "The Evolution of Russian Korean Relations", Asian Survey, 34(9), pp.789~798 (1994)
- Bouchkin, Andrew A., "Russia’s Far Eastern Policy in the 1990s, In The Making of Foreign Policy in Russia and the New States of Eurasia" (1995), M. E. Sharpe
- Cossa, Ralph A, "East Asia: Economic Interdependence and Regional Security", International Affairs (Royal Institute of International Affairs, 73(2), pp.219~234 (1997), Royal Institute of International Affairs
- Davidov, Oleg., "Soviet Policy Toward the Korean Peninsula in the 1990s", paper presented at the 10th international conference on “New Changes in International Order and the Roles of South and North Korea (1990)
- "Digital Times. April 21, 2005", ~ (2005)
- Ferdinand, Peter., "South Korea, In Politics in the Developing World" (2004), Oxford University Press
- Gorbachev, Mikhail, "Memoirs" (1996), Doubleday
- Hankook Ilbo, "September 21", ~ (2004)
- Harada, Chikahito., "Russia and Northeast Asia" (1997), Oxford University Press
- "Interview with an anonymous visiting Korean Russian specialist in Washington, DC", ~ (1997)
- Joo, Seung-Ho., "ROK-Russian Economic Relations, 1992-2001", Korea and World Affairs, 25(3), pp.366~393 (2001)
- Joo, Seung-Ho., "Russia and Korea : The Summit and After", The Korean Journal of Defence Analysis, 13(1), pp.103~127 (2001)
- Kim, Hak Joon., "Emerging Relations Between South Korea and the Soviet Union", Far Eastern Affairs, 4, pp.637~651 (1991)
- "Konseptsiya vneshnei politiki Rossiiskoi Federats", Nezavisimaya gazeta, ~ (2000)
- Korea Times, "February 17", ~ (2005)
- Korean Statistical Yearbook., "Seoul: National Statistical Office", Republic of Korea, 300~301 (1993)
- Korea-Russia Joint Declaration by Kim and Putin, "released by The Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade", Republic of Korea, ~ (2001)
- Korea-Russia Joint Declaration by Kim and Putin., "Moscow, September 21, 2004, released by The Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade", Republic of Korea, ~ (2004)
- Koronenko, Vasily., "In Seoul, Yeltsin Proposes 23 projects for Economic Cooperation with South Korea", November, 19 (1992)
- Light, Margot., "Anglo-Soviet relations: political and diplomatic, In Soviet-British Relations Since the 1970s" (1990), Cambridge University Press
- Lo, Bobo., "Vladimir Putin and the Evolution of Russian Foreign Policy" (2003), Blackwell
- "Maeil Kyongje Shinmun", 5~ (1995)
- Oberdorfer, Don., "The Two Koreas" (1997), Addison-Wesley
- Pravda, Alex., "Conclusion, In Soviet-British Relations Since the 1970s" (1990), Cambridge University Press
- "Rossiskaya Gazeta", ~ (1992)
- Rozman, Gilbert, "When Will Russia Really Enter Northeast Asia?, In The Future of the Russian State: A Sourcebook", Columbia International Affairs Online
- Rozman, Gilbert, "Russia and East Asia: the 21st Century Security Environment" (1999), M. E. Sharpe
- Shearman, Peter., "Personality, Politics and Power: Foreign Policy under Putin, In Russia After Yeltsin" (2001), Ashgate
- Soh, Yoke T., "Russian Policy toward the Two Koreas, In Russian Foreign Policy Since 1990" (1995), Westernview Press
- "South Korean Ambassador Predicts Record Trade with Russia", Interfax News Agency, ~ (2004)
- "Speech by Mikhail Gorbachev in Vladivostok" (1986), Novosti Press Agency Publishing House
- "The Current Digest of the Post-Soviet Press", 44(46), pp.15~16 (1992)
- "Briefing on Political Cooperation" (2005)[URL]
- "The Korea Herald", ~ (2001)
- Toloraya, Georgi., "President Putin’s Korean Policy", The Journal of East Asian Affairs, 17(1), pp.33~51 (2003)
- "Treaty on Basic Relations between the Republic of Korea and the Russian Federation. (1992). November 19, 1992, published by the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade, Republic of Korea, June 14", ~ (1993)
- Wishnick, Elizabeth, "Russian-North Korean Relations: A New Era, In North Korea and Northeast Asia", Rowman &Littlefield Publishers
- "Yonhap News Agency. April 20, 2005, September 21", ~ (2004)
- Ziegler, Charles E., "Foreign Policy and East Asia: Learning and Adaptation in the Gorbachev Era" (1993), Cambridge University Press