스페인의 은행업규제와 그 시사점에 관한 연구
The Study on the Spanish Banking Regulation and Its Lessons
0
조회
0
다운로드
0
인용
0
참고문헌
키워드
초록
Many countries cross the world have had severe difficulty in financial crisis originated from the United States since 2007. The European Union (hereinafter EU) that is another pillar of the world economy has been also infected with such crisis. In particular, Portugal, Ireland, Italy, Greece and Spain (hereinafter PIIGS) is at the core of this turbulence in EU. The PIIGS has a major drawback that runs State fiscal deficits. Moreover, the PIIGS has been aggravated by the PIIGS’ poor financial regulations. This means that prudent financial regulations can lessen such deficits and reduce the financial crisis of the PIIGS. The piece examines Spain among the PIIGS and concludes as follows: (1) Specialized banks cannot take deposits from the public in Spain, but they can do in Korea. (2) There is not any express provision of the supervisory and regulatory principle in Korea and Spain. However, such an express provision needs to be provided in the legislations for the legal stability. (3) The minimum capital for banking in Korea is about four times more than that in Spain. (4) In Spain, the Minister of Economy and Finance (hereinafter MEF) decides whether the banking is authorized or not, but another regulations excluding the licensing for banking are excised by another financial regulator, the Bank of Spain (hereinafter BS). On the other hand, one financial regulator, Financial Services Commission (hereinafter FSC) excises all sorts of financial regulations in Korea. (5) There is a preliminary approval process in Korea, but not in Spain. (6) – (7) There are discriminated investment limits and limits of holding bank’s shares based on receivers and shareholders in Korea, but not in Spain. (8) An internal control mechanism is provided in both countries, but the compliance officer is introduced to Korea, not Spain. (9) A prompt corrective action is adopted by Korea, not Spain. (10) Even though an on-site inspection is provided in Korea and Spain, its expansion into other subjects including banks needs to be examined. (11) There are many detailed provisions for the cooperation of the supervisory and regulatory approach in Spain, but not in Korea. (12) While any start-up banking company cannot pay dividends to its shareholders without the BS’s permission for three years, there is any regulation in Korea. (13) Any start-up banking company cannot give credit to its directors for five years in Spain, not in Korea. (14) The BS may send interim directors to so extremely troubled banks in Spain, not Korea. On the other hand, the Korean banking authority can just recommend that the general meeting of any bank dismiss its director from his or her directorship.
Abstract
Many countries cross the world have had severe difficulty in financial crisis originated from the United States since 2007. The European Union (hereinafter EU) that is another pillar of the world economy has been also infected with such crisis. In particular, Portugal, Ireland, Italy, Greece and Spain (hereinafter PIIGS) is at the core of this turbulence in EU. The PIIGS has a major drawback that runs State fiscal deficits. Moreover, the PIIGS has been aggravated by the PIIGS’ poor financial regulations. This means that prudent financial regulations can lessen such deficits and reduce the financial crisis of the PIIGS. The piece examines Spain among the PIIGS and concludes as follows: (1) Specialized banks cannot take deposits from the public in Spain, but they can do in Korea. (2) There is not any express provision of the supervisory and regulatory principle in Korea and Spain. However, such an express provision needs to be provided in the legislations for the legal stability. (3) The minimum capital for banking in Korea is about four times more than that in Spain. (4) In Spain, the Minister of Economy and Finance (hereinafter MEF) decides whether the banking is authorized or not, but another regulations excluding the licensing for banking are excised by another financial regulator, the Bank of Spain (hereinafter BS). On the other hand, one financial regulator, Financial Services Commission (hereinafter FSC) excises all sorts of financial regulations in Korea. (5) There is a preliminary approval process in Korea, but not in Spain. (6) – (7) There are discriminated investment limits and limits of holding bank’s shares based on receivers and shareholders in Korea, but not in Spain. (8) An internal control mechanism is provided in both countries, but the compliance officer is introduced to Korea, not Spain. (9) A prompt corrective action is adopted by Korea, not Spain. (10) Even though an on-site inspection is provided in Korea and Spain, its expansion into other subjects including banks needs to be examined. (11) There are many detailed provisions for the cooperation of the supervisory and regulatory approach in Spain, but not in Korea. (12) While any start-up banking company cannot pay dividends to its shareholders without the BS’s permission for three years, there is any regulation in Korea. (13) Any start-up banking company cannot give credit to its directors for five years in Spain, not in Korea. (14) The BS may send interim directors to so extremely troubled banks in Spain, not Korea. On the other hand, the Korean banking authority can just recommend that the general meeting of any bank dismiss its director from his or her directorship.
참고문헌 (15)
- 강유덕, "남유럽 경제위기의 본질과 향후 전망", 오늘의 세계경제, 10(12) (2010), 대외경제정책연구원
- 김필헌, "PIIGS 국가부도 위기의 교훈", KERI Insight (2010), 한국경제연구원
- 백정웅, "한국 금융지주회사에 대한 적기시정 조치", 원광법학, 23(2), pp.365~404 (2007), 법학연구소
- 윤원섭, "PIGS 망하면 獨·佛 은행 줄도산", 매일경제(2011.4.22.), ~ (2011)
- 이명준, "스페인과 닮은꼴 한국, 위기대책도 그대로?", 참세상(2012.6.23.), ~ (2012)
- 금융기관 적기시정조치의 실효성 제고방안 연구, "재정경제부", 재정경제부·한국개발연구원, ~ (2004)
- 정성택, "이탈리아 빚 PIGS보다 많아…"세계경제 잃어버린 10년 온다", 한국경제(2011.11.11.), ~ (2011)
- 한국개발연구원, "적기시정조치 제도 개선", 한국개발연구원, ~ (2005)
- Juan Carlos Machuca, "The Banking Regulation Review", pp.677~ (2012)
- Michael K. O’Neal, "Update on Prompt Corrective Action and Other Regulatory Enforcement Powers", Consumer Fin. L.Q. Rep, 48, pp.259~ (1994)
- Philomila Tsoukala, "Narratives of the European Crisis and the Future of (Social) Europe", Tex. Int'l L.J, 48, pp.241~ (2013)
- Roberta S. Karmel, "The Controversy over Systemic Risk Regulation", Brook. J. Int’l L, 35, pp.823~ (2010)
- The World Bank, "Gross domestic product 2012", The World Bank, Sep. 23, ~ (2013)
- The World Bank, "World Bank Survey III - June 2008 (MS Excel file, 768kb)", The World Bank, ~ (2012)
- Uría Menéndez, "Bank Finance and Regulation Survey: SPAIN", ~ (2011)
